Annulment and legal separation are two distinct legal remedies for troubled marriages, primarily differing in their effect on the marital bond and the time the grounds occurred.
Here are the key distinctions between the two:
- Status of the Marital Bond:
- Annulment dissolves and terminates the marital bond, allowing the former spouses to freely remarry.
- Legal Separation merely permits the spouses to live separately from each other (separation from bed and board). The marriage bond is not severed, and the parties are not allowed to remarry.
- Defect in the Marriage:
- Annulment applies to a marriage that was already defective at the very beginning (a voidable marriage) due to issues like vitiated consent or incapacity.
- Legal Separation applies to a marriage that was perfectly valid and had no defect at the beginning.
- Time of the Cause:
- In Annulment, the cause or ground (e.g., fraud, intimidation, impotence, or psychological incapacity in related nullity cases) must already be existing at the time of the marriage celebration.
- In Legal Separation, the cause (e.g., sexual infidelity, abandonment, physical violence) arises after the marriage celebration.
- Number of Grounds: The law provides fewer grounds for annulment (such as lack of parental consent, insanity, fraud, force, impotence, and serious STDs). On the other hand, there are exactly ten (10) exclusive statutory grounds for legal separation.
Similarities:
Despite these differences, both remedies share some common legal consequences. Both result in the dissolution and liquidation of the absolute community or conjugal partnership property regime. Additionally, in both cases, the guilty spouse or the spouse who acted in bad faith forfeits their share in the net profits of the property regime.
English