ABC Construction Company was engaged by XYZ Group Inc. to build an eight-storey building with a height of 34.4 meters located behind the intended new airport in Bulacan. A month later, Ordinance No. 12345 was passed by the Sangguniang Panlalawigan of Bulacan, setting the height limit on the buildings to be constructed along the new airport to five storeys or a maximum height of 21.5 meters. After building five storeys, ABC Construction Company served a notice on XYZ Group Inc. that it can no longer build the sixth, seventh, and eighth floors of the building in view of Ordinance No. 12345. XYZ Group Inc. consequently assailed Ordinance No. 12345 for allegedly violating the non-impairment clause of the Constitution. Will the case prosper? Reason(s).
Suggested answer only. Not an official answer and not legal advice.
No, the case filed by XYZ Group Inc. will not prosper.
Under Constitutional Law, the non-impairment clause is limited by and subject to the legitimate exercise of the State's police power for public safety and general welfare. In every contract, there is an implied reservation that it yields to valid police power measures enacted for the public good.
Here, Ordinance No. 12345 is a valid police power measure enacted by the LGU under the General Welfare Clause to ensure aviation and public safety near the new airport. Although the building height limit prevents the construction of the remaining three floors, the private contract between XYZ Group Inc. and ABC Construction Company must yield to the overriding demands of public welfare.
Therefore, Ordinance No. 12345 is constitutional, and XYZ Group Inc.'s case alleging a violation of the non-impairment clause must be dismissed.
This is not an official scoring system and carries no weight with the Supreme Court or any bar review provider. It measures how much of the suggested answer's wording your response covers, not whether your reasoning is correct. For practice only.
Quick check
Will XYZ Group Inc.'s petition to invalidate the ordinance based on the non-impairment clause prosper?
The non-impairment clause is subordinate to the State's police power, which is impliedly reserved in every contract to promote public and aviation safety.
How does the constitutional non-impairment clause interact with the State's inherent police power?
All private contracts are executed subject to the sovereign police power of the State to regulate rights for the general welfare.
What is a necessary condition for a local government ordinance to be a valid exercise of delegated police power?
An LGU ordinance exercising police power is valid when it addresses a lawful subject through a lawful method and accords with the Constitution and statutes.
Under what authority may a provincial board enact height restrictions on structures constructed near an airport?
Local government units enact building height limits near airports as a valid exercise of delegated police power under the General Welfare Clause to ensure public safety.
Why is ABC Construction Company legally excused from building the top three storeys of the contracted building?
Compliance with a valid police power ordinance renders performance of the prohibited portion of a contract unlawful, thereby excusing the contractor from proceeding.
Learn more about these topics
1. Police Power
Police power is the inherent power of the State to enact regulations promoting public health, safety, morals, and general welfare. Considered the most pervasive of the State's inherent powers, its valid exercise may restrict individual liberty and property rights without monetary compensation. Public safety and general welfare objectives override private rights whenever there is a concurrence of a lawful subject and a lawful method.
2. Non-Impairment Clause
The constitutional non-impairment clause protects valid contractual obligations against subsequent legislative alteration. However, this guarantee is not absolute and must yield to the State's paramount police power. Private contracts are deemed executed with the implied reservation that the State may enact reasonable measures to safeguard public safety and interest. Consequently, valid police regulations modifying contractual terms do not violate the non-impairment clause.
3. General Welfare Clause
Local government units exercise delegated police power primarily through their legislative bodies pursuant to the General Welfare Clause of the Local Government Code. An ordinance exercising delegated police power is constitutionally valid if it serves a public interest through a reasonable method without conflicting with the Constitution or existing national statutes. Enacting building height limitations near airport facilities constitutes a legitimate exercise of this power to safeguard aviation safety.