State whether or not the following acts are constitutional: (2% each)
(a) A law prescribing as qualifications for appointment to any court lower than the Supreme Court, Philippine citizenship, whether natural-born or naturalized, 35 years of age on the date of appointment, and at least eight years as a member of the Philippine Bar;
(b) A law requiring all candidates for national or local elective offices to be college degree holders;
(c) The designation by the President of an acting Associate Commissioner of the Civil Service Commission;
(d) The appointment by the President as Deputy Ombudsman of a lawyer who has been engaged in the practice of law for five years; and
(e) The nomination by a national party-list of a person who is not one of its bona fide members.
Suggested answer only. Not an official answer and not legal advice.
(a) Unconstitutional in part. (b) Unconstitutional in part. (c) Unconstitutional. (d) Constitutional. (e) Unconstitutional.
Under the Constitution, lower collegiate court judges must be natural-born, national elective qualifications are exclusive, and Constitutional Commission members cannot be designated acting. Further, a Deputy Ombudsman needs no 10-year practice, and party-list nominees must be bona fide members.
Here, allowing naturalized judges for lower collegiate courts and requiring degrees for national candidates violate constitutional limits. Designating an acting Commissioner violates Article IX. Five years of practice suffices for Deputy Ombudsman, and nominating a non-member violates RA 7941.
Therefore, acts (a) in part, (b) in part, (c), and (e) are unconstitutional, whereas (d) is constitutional.
This is not an official scoring system and carries no weight with the Supreme Court or any bar review provider. It measures how much of the suggested answer's wording your response covers, not whether your reasoning is correct. For practice only.
Quick check
Why is a law permitting naturalized citizens to be appointed to lower collegiate courts unconstitutional?
Article VIII, Section 7 of the Constitution explicitly mandates natural-born citizenship for members of lower collegiate courts.
Why is a statutory requirement of a college degree for presidential candidates unconstitutional?
Constitutional qualifications for national elective offices are exclusive and cannot be altered or added to by Congress.
Why is the presidential designation of an acting Associate Commissioner of the Civil Service Commission void?
Article IX of the Constitution strictly prohibits temporary or acting designations for Constitutional Commission members.
Does the 10-year law practice requirement under Article XI, Section 8 apply to a Deputy Ombudsman?
Article XI, Section 8 requires ten years of practice for the Ombudsman only, so members of the Bar with five years of practice are eligible as Deputies.
What is the legal requirement regarding the party membership of a national party-list nominee?
Under RA 7941 and settled jurisprudence, a party-list nominee must be a bona fide member of the nominating party.
Learn more about these topics
1. Judicial Qualifications Rules
Under Article VIII, Section 7 of the 1987 Constitution, Members of the Supreme Court and lower collegiate courts must be natural-born citizens of the Philippines. For lower collegiate courts, such as the Court of Appeals, Sandiganbayan, and Court of Tax Appeals, the requirement of natural-born citizenship is explicitly mandated by the Constitution. Congress cannot by law alter or reduce this qualification by permitting naturalized citizens to be appointed. However, for lower trial courts, Congress possesses statutory authority to prescribe qualifications, where naturalized citizenship may be allowed by statute.
2. Elective Office Qualifications
Under established constitutional law jurisprudence, the qualifications prescribed by the Constitution for national elective offices—such as the President, Vice-President, Senators, and Members of the House of Representatives—are exclusive and exhaustive. Congress cannot add to, subtract from, or alter these constitutional qualifications by passing ordinary legislation. Consequently, a statute requiring candidates for national offices to be college degree holders is unconstitutional. However, for local elective offices, Congress retains statutory discretion under the Local Government Code to prescribe additional reasonable qualifications, provided they do not violate constitutional guarantees.
3. Constitutional Commission Acting
Under Article IX-A, Section 1 and Article IX-B, Section 1(2) of the 1987 Constitution, Members of the Constitutional Commissions—including the Civil Service Commission—shall be appointed by the President with the consent of the Commission on Appointments. The Constitution strictly prohibits appointing or designating any member of a Constitutional Commission in a temporary or acting capacity. This constitutional ban safeguards the independence of executive oversight bodies. Thus, any presidential designation of an acting Associate Commissioner of the Civil Service Commission is unconstitutional and void.