Nympha, a famous author, collaborated with Tobias, a novice illustrator, to create a children’s book. Tobias offered his services for free. Nympha gave Tobias the manuscript and discussed with him the inspiration for the characters. Nympha envisioned a story about two best friends who had a huge fight but later realized the value of forgiveness. Tobias drew the characters based on Nympha’s specifications and instructions. Nympha then published the book and claimed sole copyright ownership. Nympha argued that she is the author not only of the text but also the images in the book since Tobias exactly adopted her idea. Is Nympha the copyright owner of the images or drawings in the book? Explain.
Suggested answer only. Not an official answer and not legal advice.
No, Nympha is not the copyright owner of the drawings or images in the book.
Under Sections 175 and 178 of the Intellectual Property Code (R.A. No. 8293), copyright protection extends only to the expression of an idea, not to ideas or concepts as such. Copyright belongs to the actual creator from the moment of creation. If a work consists of parts that can be used separately, the author of each part owns the copyright in that part.
Here, Nympha merely provided the manuscript, ideas, and character specifications, which are unprotected subject matter. Tobias actually rendered and created the visual drawings. Although Tobias drew them based on Nympha's instructions, Nympha did not acquire copyright over Tobias's artistic creations.
Therefore, Nympha is not the copyright owner of the drawings or images in the book.
This is not an official scoring system and carries no weight with the Supreme Court or any bar review provider. It measures how much of the suggested answer's wording your response covers, not whether your reasoning is correct. For practice only.
Quick check
Under Section 175 of the Intellectual Property Code, what aspect of a literary or artistic creation is protected by copyright?
Copyright protection extends exclusively to the original tangible expression of an idea, not to the idea itself.
Who is the original owner of copyright in an illustration drawn based on another person's verbal instructions?
Copyright vests originally in the actual creator who renders the visual expression, regardless of who provided the initial instructions.
How is copyright ownership allocated when a children's book consists of separable text and illustrations created by different persons?
When a work consists of separable parts, the creator of each distinct part owns the copyright in her respective contribution.
Does providing an illustrator with plot ideas and character descriptions make a writer the owner of the resulting drawings?
Unexpressed ideas and character descriptions are unprotected subject matter that do not confer copyright ownership over visual drawings.
What requirement must be satisfied to transfer copyright ownership of illustrations from an illustrator to an author?
Under Philippine copyright law, any transfer or assignment of copyright ownership must be executed in writing.
Learn more about these topics
1. Idea-Expression Dichotomy
Under Section 175 of the Intellectual Property Code (R.A. No. 8293), copyright protection extends exclusively to the tangible expression of an idea, not to the underlying idea, concept, or system itself. An author who provides abstract themes, plot ideas, or character specifications does not acquire copyright in the visual illustrations created by an artist. The person who translates ideas into tangible artistic drawings is the sole creator and owner of the copyright in those specific visual expressions.
2. Copyright Ownership Creation
Under Section 178 of the Intellectual Property Code, copyright vests originally in the actual creator of the work from the moment of its creation. Even if an illustrator renders artistic services free of charge or follows detailed instructions, the client or collaborator does not automatically become the copyright owner of the drawings. Unless there is a written assignment of copyright transferring ownership, the creator retains all statutory intellectual property rights over the original illustrations.
3. Joint Work Ownership
When a literary and artistic creation consists of distinct and separate parts—such as text and illustrations in a children's book—the author of each separable part holds independent copyright ownership over her respective contribution. Unless the collaborators explicitly agree in writing to create a joint work with shared ownership, the writer owns the copyright to the manuscript, while the illustrator owns the copyright to the original visual artwork.