Yolanda executed and signed a promissory note with all the requisites for negotiability being present, except for the amount which was left blank. She kept the promissory note in her desk and decided to place the amount at a later date. The indicated payee, Yohann, managed to obtain the promissory note from Yolanda’s desk and filled out the amount for the sum of PhP 10 million, which was the amount actually lent by him to Yolanda, but excluding the agreed interest. Yohann later endorsed and delivered the check to Yvette, under circumstances that would constitute the latter to be a holder in due course.
(a) May Yvette hold Yolanda liable on the note? (2.5%)
(b) Would your answer be the same if the promissory note was actually completed by Yolanda (including the amount of PhP 10 million), but stolen from her desk by Yohann? Can Yvette enforce the note against Yolanda? (2.5%)
Suggested answer only. Not an official answer and not legal advice.
(a) No, Yvette cannot hold Yolanda liable. (b) No, the answer is not the same; Yvette can enforce the note against Yolanda.
Under Section 15 of the Negotiable Instruments Law (NIL), an incomplete and undelivered instrument is not a valid contract in the hands of any holder, including a holder in due course. Under Section 16 of the NIL, where a complete instrument is in the hands of a holder in due course, a valid delivery by all prior parties is conclusively presumed.
Here, in (a), the note was incomplete and undelivered, making Section 15 a real defense against Yvette. In (b), because the note was complete when stolen, lack of delivery is a personal defense under Section 16, which is unavailable against Yvette as a holder in due course.
Therefore, Yolanda is not liable on the incomplete note in (a), but is liable to Yvette on the complete note in (b).
This is not an official scoring system and carries no weight with the Supreme Court or any bar review provider. It measures how much of the suggested answer's wording your response covers, not whether your reasoning is correct. For practice only.
Quick check
Under Section 15 of the Negotiable Instruments Law, what is the legal effect of an incomplete and undelivered instrument?
Section 15 provides that an incomplete and undelivered instrument is not a valid contract in the hands of any holder.
Why is non-delivery of a complete instrument ineffective as a defense against a holder in due course under Section 16?
Section 16 provides that a valid delivery by all prior parties is conclusively presumed in favor of a holder in due course.
Which type of defense is the defense of an incomplete and undelivered instrument under Section 15 of Act Number 2031?
Section 15 creates a real defense that can be asserted against any holder, including a holder in due course.
If a complete promissory note is stolen from the maker's desk and negotiated to a holder in due course, can the maker be held liable?
Lack of delivery of a complete instrument is a personal defense, which is ineffective against a holder in due course under Section 16.
Which statute governs negotiable instruments, real and personal defenses, and holder in due course rights in the Philippines?
Act Number 2031 is the Negotiable Instruments Law governing negotiable instruments and defenses.
Learn more about these topics
1. Incomplete Undelivered Instrument
Under Section 15 of the Negotiable Instruments Law (Act Number 2031), where an incomplete instrument has not been delivered, it will not, if completed and negotiated without authority, be a valid contract in the hands of any holder, as against any person whose signature was placed thereon before delivery. The combination of incompleteness and lack of delivery constitutes a real defense available against any holder, including a holder in due course. Consequently, a signer whose incomplete note was stolen and subsequently completed and negotiated incurs no legal liability to any subsequent holder.
2. Complete Undelivered Instrument
Under Section 16 of Act Number 2031, where an instrument is in the hands of a holder in due course, a valid delivery thereof by all parties prior to him is conclusively presumed. When an instrument is complete in all its material terms but is stolen prior to delivery, the defense of lack of delivery is merely a personal defense. While non-delivery can be asserted against immediate parties or remote holders who are not holders in due course, it cannot be raised against a holder in due course, who can enforce the note according to its tenor.
3. Real Personal Defenses
In negotiable instruments law, a real defense attaches to the instrument itself and can be set up against any holder, including a holder in due course, because no valid contract ever came into legal existence. In contrast, a personal defense arises from agreement equities or defective delivery among immediate parties and cannot be asserted against a holder in due course. Section 15 creates a real defense because both incompleteness and non-delivery prevent contract formation, whereas Section 16 creates a conclusive presumption of valid delivery protecting holders in due course.