Sol Soldivino, widow, passed away, leaving two (2) legitimate children: a 25- year old son, Santino (whom she had not spoken to for five [5] years prior to her death since he attempted to kill her at that time), and a 20-year-old daughter, Sara. She left an estate worth PhP8 million and a will containing only one provision: that PhP1 million should be given to “the priest who officiated at my wedding to my children’s late father.” Sara, together with two (2) of her friends, acted as an attesting witness to the will.
On the assumption that the will is admitted for probate and that there are no debts, divide the estate and indicate the heirs/legatees entitled to inherit, the amount that each of them will inherit, and where (i.e., legitime/free portion/intestate share) their shares should be charged. (5%)
Suggested answer only. Not an official answer and not legal advice.
Santino and Sara get ₱3.5 million each, while the priest receives a ₱1 million legacy.
Under Article 888, legitimate children share a 1/2 legitime. Under Articles 916 and 1032(2), unworthiness or disinheritance requires a written cause or final conviction. Article 823 voids legacies to witnesses, not compulsory shares. Article 1027(1) disqualifies only last-illness confessors.
Here, Santino was neither convicted nor disinherited, while witness Sara is a compulsory heir. The priest merely officiated Sol's wedding. From ₱8 million, ₱4 million is legitime (₱2M each). The ₱4 million free portion pays the ₱1M legacy, leaving ₱3M shared equally (₱1.5M each).
Therefore, Santino and Sara inherit ₱3.5 million each (₱2M legitime, ₱1.5M free portion), and the priest gets ₱1 million.
This is not an official scoring system and carries no weight with the Supreme Court or any bar review provider. It measures how much of the suggested answer's wording your response covers, not whether your reasoning is correct. For practice only.
Quick check
Under Article 888 of the Civil Code, what portion of the estate constitutes the compulsory legitime of legitimate children?
Under Article 888, the legitime of legitimate children consists of one-half of the hereditary estate of the parents.
Under Article 1032(2) of the Civil Code, what is required for an attempt on the life of the testator to cause incapacity by unworthiness?
Incapacity to succeed by unworthiness under Article 1032(2) requires a final judicial conviction for the attempt against life.
Under Article 823 of the Civil Code, what is the legal effect when a compulsory heir acts as an attesting witness to a will?
Article 823 voids legacies or devises given to attesting witnesses, but does not affect their compulsory legitimes or intestate shares.
Under Article 1027(1) of the Civil Code, which priest is disqualified from inheriting from a decedent's estate?
Article 1027(1) disqualifies only the priest who heard the confession of the deceased during her last illness.
In the estate of Sol, why did Santino and Sara each inherit ₱3.5 million from the total ₱8 million estate?
Santino and Sara each received their ₱2 million legitime plus an equal ₱1.5 million share of the undisposed free portion.
Learn more about these topics
1. Legitimes and Intestacy
Under Article 888 of the Civil Code, the legitime of legitimate children consists of one-half of the hereditary estate of the father and mother, split equally among them. The remaining half constitutes the free portion, which the testator may dispose of by will subject to existing rights. Where a will disposes of only a portion of the free portion through a legacy, the remaining undisposed free portion is distributed by operation of law through intestate succession among the legal heirs.
2. Disinheritance and Unworthiness
Under Article 916 of the Civil Code, disinheritance can be effected only through a valid will wherein the legal cause therefor shall be specified. Under Article 1032, paragraph 2, a person convicted of an attempt against the life of the testator is incapable of succeeding by reason of unworthiness. An attempt on the life of the parent without a final judicial conviction or an express disinheritance in a valid will does not deprive a legitimate child of his legitime or intestate share.
3. Capacity to Inherit
Under Article 823 of the Civil Code, a legacy or devise given to an attesting witness to a will is void, but this prohibition does not forfeit or affect the compulsory legitime or intestate share belonging to such witness as a legal heir. Furthermore, under Article 1027, paragraph 1, the disqualification of a priest applies strictly to the priest who heard the confession of the deceased during her last illness, and does not extend to a priest who merely officiated at the marriage of the deceased.