Rakham operates the lending company that made a loan to Alfonso in the amount of Pl20,000.00 subject of a promissory note which is due within one (1) year from the note’s issuance. Three years after the loan became due and upon information that Alfonso is nowhere to be found, Rakham asks you for advice on how to treat the obligation as “bad debt.” Discuss the requisites for deductibility of a “bad debt?” (5%)
Suggested answer only. Not an official answer and not legal advice.
Rakham should treat Alfonso's obligation as a bad debt deduction from gross income upon proving its worthlessness.
Under Section 34(E)(1) of the NIRC and RR No. 05-99, bad debts are deductible if: (1) valid and demandable debt exists; (2) connected with business; (3) not between related parties; (4) actually charged off within the taxable year; and (5) ascertained to be worthless despite diligent efforts.
Rakham's ₱120,000 loan arises from his lending business. Because the loan is 3 years overdue and Alfonso cannot be found, the debt may be ascertained as worthless. Rakham must charge off the debt in his books within the taxable year.
Thus, Rakham can deduct the obligation as a bad debt after charging it off and demonstrating that collection efforts failed.
This is not an official scoring system and carries no weight with the Supreme Court or any bar review provider. It measures how much of the suggested answer's wording your response covers, not whether your reasoning is correct. For practice only.
Quick check
Which section of the National Internal Revenue Code governs the deductibility of bad debts from gross income?
Section 34(E) of the National Internal Revenue Code governs allowable deductions for bad debts.
What is required to satisfy the element of worthlessness for a bad debt deduction when a debtor disappears?
Proving that diligent collection efforts failed because the debtor is nowhere to be found satisfies the element of worthlessness.
When must a bad debt be actually charged off in the taxpayer's books of account to be deductible?
Bad debts must be actually charged off in the books of account within the taxable year they are determined to be worthless.
Which obligation is disqualified from being claimed as a bad debt deduction under Section 34(E) of the NIRC?
Debts between related taxpayers under Section 36(B) of the NIRC are disqualified from being claimed as bad debt deductions.
How does a lending company treat a worthless business loan for income tax purposes?
A worthless business loan is claimed as an itemized deduction from gross income upon satisfying all statutory requisites.
Learn more about these topics
1. Bad Debts Requisites
Under Section 34(E)(1) of the National Internal Revenue Code, bad debts are allowable deductions from gross income provided specific statutory requisites are satisfied. There must be a valid, subsisting, and legally demandable debt connected with the taxpayer's trade, business, or profession. The debt must not be between related parties as defined under tax laws. Furthermore, the obligation must be actually charged off in the taxpayer's books of accounts within the taxable year and ascertained to be worthless despite diligent and reasonable efforts exerted to collect the amount due from the debtor.
2. Ascertainment of Worthlessness
Ascertainment of worthlessness requires proof that reasonable and diligent collection efforts were exerted by the creditor but proved futile. The determination of worthlessness depends upon the specific surrounding facts and circumstances of each case, such as the insolvency or disappearance of the debtor. Where a debtor is nowhere to be found or possesses no leviable assets to satisfy the obligation, the creditor is not required to engage in useless legal proceedings. Demonstrating that the debtor cannot be located or is completely insolvent satisfies the legal requirement of worthlessness for bad debt deduction.
3. Book Charge Off
The requirement that a bad debt must be actually charged off within the taxable year means that the obligation must be eliminated from the taxpayer's assets on its books of account. The accounting entry charging off the bad debt must be made within the same taxable year that the debt is determined to be worthless. Writing off the uncollectible account reflects the true financial condition of the enterprise. Failure to charge off the obligation in the books of account during the corresponding taxable year will result in the disallowance of the bad debt deduction.