Atty. Jessa was the counsel for Mr. Nolan, a cantankerous millionaire, in the latter’s personal case. Soon after the case was submitted for decision, Mr. Nolan withdrew the files from Atty. Jessa and informed her that he was engaging another lawyer. On that same day, a copy of the decision in the case was received by Atty. Jessa but she did not do anything anymore with the decision. She did not also file a withdrawal of her appearance. Mr. Nolan’s new counsel did not file any notice of his appearance. By the time Mr. Nolan found out about the adverse decision, his period to appeal had lapsed.
Was the service of the decision on Atty. Jessa still effective? Explain your answer. (4%)
Suggested answer only. Not an official answer and not legal advice.
Yes, the service of the decision on Atty. Jessa was still effective.
Under Rule 13, Section 2 of the Rules of Court and settled jurisprudence, service of judgments upon the counsel of record is legally binding on the client. To sever the attorney-client relationship before the court, a formal substitution of counsel or withdrawal of appearance with court approval must be filed on record.
Here, although Mr. Nolan retrieved his files and informally hired a new lawyer, Atty. Jessa remained the counsel of record because no formal withdrawal or new appearance was filed. Consequently, service of the decision on Atty. Jessa was valid and binding on Mr. Nolan, causing the period to appeal to lapse.
Therefore, the service of the decision on Atty. Jessa was effective, and Mr. Nolan is bound by her receipt.
This is not an official scoring system and carries no weight with the Supreme Court or any bar review provider. It measures how much of the suggested answer's wording your response covers, not whether your reasoning is correct. For practice only.
Quick check
Under Rule 13, Section 2 of the Rules of Court, upon whom must service of court decisions and orders be made when a party is represented by an attorney?
Service of notices and judgments upon a represented party must be made on counsel of record unless otherwise ordered by the court.
What is required to validly effectuate a substitution of counsel in a pending case before the trial court?
Valid substitution of counsel requires written consent of the client, consent or notice to former counsel, and court approval.
What is the legal effect of serving a court decision upon an attorney of record who was informally discharged by her client without court approval?
Service on counsel of record remains valid and binding on the client until formal substitution is filed.
When does the period to appeal a court judgment begin to run for a represented litigant?
The period to appeal begins upon receipt of the judgment by the counsel of record.
What happens to a judgment when counsel of record receives a copy but fails to appeal due to informal dismissal by the client?
Failure to appeal after valid service on counsel of record causes the judgment to become final and executory.
Learn more about these topics
1. Counsel of Record
Under Rule 13, Section 2 of the Rules of Court, when a party is represented by an attorney, service of court notices, orders, and judgments must be made upon the counsel of record unless service upon the party himself is expressly ordered by the court. The attorney of record remains the official legal representative in the eyes of the court until a formal discharge or substitution is effected. Notice to counsel of record is legally deemed notice to the client, regardless of private arrangements or informal disputes between them.
2. Substitution of Counsel
To effect a valid substitution of counsel in a pending judicial proceeding, three essential requisites must concur: (1) filing of a written application for substitution; (2) written consent of the client; and (3) written consent of the attorney to be substituted or proof of service of notice to him. Until these procedural requirements are formally submitted and approved by the court, the attorney of record continues to be recognized as counsel, and court papers served on her remain legally binding on the client.
3. Binding Service Rule
When a decision or final order is officially served upon the counsel of record, the period within which to file an appeal or motion for reconsideration begins to run immediately. Informal retrieval of case records or unrecorded employment of a new lawyer does not terminate the counsel of record's authority before the court. Consequently, the failure of counsel of record or new counsel to take timely remedial action after valid service of judgment causes the judgment to become final and executory.