2017 Civil Law, Q16

Jovencio operated a school bus to ferry his two sons and five of their schoolmates from their houses to their school, and back. The parents of the five schoolmates paid for the service. One morning, Porfirio, the driver, took a short cut on the way to school because he was running late, and drove across an unmanned railway crossing. At the time, Porfirio was wearing earphones because he loved to hear loud music while driving. As he crossed the railway tracks, a speeding PNR train loudly blared its horn to warn Porfirio, but the latter did not hear the horn because of the loud music. The train inevitably rammed into the school bus. The strong impact of the collision between the school bus and the train resulted in the instant death of one of the classmates of Jovencio’s younger son.
The parents of the fatality sued Jovencio for damages based on culpa contractual alleging that Jovencio was a common carrier; Porfirio for being negligent; and the PNR for damages based on culpa aquiliana.
Jovencio denied being a common carrier. He insisted that he had exercised the diligence of a good father of a family in supervising Porfirio, claiming that the latter had had no history of negligence or recklessness before the fatal accident.
(a) Did his operation of the school bus service for a limited clientele render Jovencio a common carrier? Explain your answer. (3%)
(b) In accordance with your answer to the preceding question, state the degree of diligence to be observed by Jovencio, and the consequences thereof. Explain your answer. (3%)
(c) Assuming that the fatality was a minor of only 15 years of age who had no earning capacity at the time of his death because he was still a student in high school, and the trial court is minded to award indemnity, what may possibly be the legal and factual justifications for the award of loss of earning capacity? Explain your answer. (4%)

Quick check

Under Article 1732 of the Civil Code, why is a school bus operator serving a limited clientele classified as a common carrier?

What degree of diligence is required of a common carrier transporting passengers under Article 1755 of the Civil Code?

In an action for breach of contract of carriage (culpa contractual), why is the defense of exercising diligence in selecting employees invalid?

How is the loss of earning capacity computed for a deceased high school student with no actual earnings at the time of death?

Choices available with full access.

When a passenger dies due to the negligence of a common carrier's driver, what is the legal nature of the carrier's liability?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Common Carrier Concept
Under Article 1732 of the Civil Code, common carriers are persons, corporations, firms or associations engaged in the business of carrying or transporting passengers or goods or both, by land, water, or air, for compensation, offering their services to the public. The law does not distinguish between a carrier offering services to the general public and one offering services to a limited clientele. Consequently, operating a school bus service for fee-paying passengers renders the operator a common carrier bound by statutory duties regardless of the limited number of patrons served.

2. Extraordinary Diligence Duty
Under Articles 1733 and 1755 of the Civil Code, common carriers are bound to observe extraordinary diligence for the safety of the passengers transported by them, according to all the circumstances of each case. In an action based on culpa contractual, proof of injury or death to a passenger creates a presumption of fault or negligence against the common carrier. The defense of exercising the diligence of a good father of a family in the selection and supervision of employees is unavailable to exempt the common carrier from contractual liability.

3. Minor Earning Capacity
Under Philippine jurisprudence, the loss of earning capacity of a deceased minor student who possessed no actual earnings at the time of death is compensable. The legal and factual justification lies in the reasonable expectation that the minor, upon reaching productive age, would have earned income and contributed to the family. Damages for loss of earning capacity are computed based on the prevailing minimum wage and life expectancy, calculated using the legal formula with work life commencing at age twenty-one.

About these questions and answers
The questions reproduced here are the official texts of the Philippine Bar Examinations, published by the Supreme Court. They are reproduced for study purposes.The suggested answers are the author’s own.

They are not official answers, have no connection with the Supreme Court, the Office of the Bar Confidant, or any bar review institution, and are not endorsed by any of them. Official answer keys, where released, should be preferred over anything here.Nothing on this page is legal advice, and reading it creates no lawyer-client relationship. Do not rely on any suggested answer in an actual legal matter. Consult counsel on your own facts.Suggested answers reflect the law and jurisprudence the author considers applicable as of the date shown.

Where a question comes from an earlier examination, the suggested answer applies the law as it now stands, which may differ from the law in force when the question was given, and may therefore differ from what would have been the correct answer at that time. Where the difference is material, the answer notes it.The practice scoring feature measures wording overlap with the suggested answer. It is not a grade, carries no official weight, and says nothing about whether your reasoning is sound.Errors are possible. If you find one, please tell me and I will correct it.Last reviewed: October 2026