2018 Civil Law, Q19

Sebastian, who has a pending assessment from the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR), was required to post a bond. He entered into an agreement with Solid Surety Company (SSC) for SSC to issue a bond in favor of the BIR to secure payment of his taxes, if found to be due. In consideration of the issuance of the bond, he executed an Indemnity Agreement with SSC whereby he agreed to indemnify the latter in the event that he was found liable to pay the tax. The BIR eventually decided against Sebastian, and judicially commenced action against both Sebastian and SSC to recover Sebastian’s unpaid taxes. Simultaneously, BIR also initiated action to foreclose on the bond. Even before paying the BIR, SSC sought indemnity from Sebastian on the basis of the Indemnity Agreement. Sebastian refused to pay since SSC had not paid the BIR anything yet, and alleged that the provision in the Indemnity Agreement which allowed SSC to recover from him, by mere demand, even if it (SSC) had not yet paid the creditor, was void for being contrary to law and public policy.
Can Sebastian legally refuse to pay SSC? (2.5%)

Quick check

Under Security Bank and Trust Co. v. Globe Assurance Co., when may a surety seek indemnity from the principal debtor under an express indemnity agreement?

Under Article 1306 of the Civil Code, what limits the freedom of contracting parties to establish contractual stipulations?

Under Article 2071 of the Civil Code, when may a guarantor or surety proceed against the principal debtor even before paying?

Why was Sebastian's refusal to indemnify Solid Surety Company (SSC) legally unmeritorious?

Choices available with full access.

What is the legal effect of a contractual provision allowing a surety to recover from the principal debtor upon mere demand before paying the creditor?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Indemnity Agreement Validity
Under Security Bank and Trust Co. v. Globe Assurance Co., a stipulation in an indemnity agreement allowing the surety to recover from the principal debtor as soon as liability attaches under the bond—even before actual payment by the surety to the creditor—is valid and enforceable. Such a stipulation does not violate law, morals, good customs, public order, or public policy. The liability of the indemnitor arises directly from the contractual agreement executed between the parties.

2. Freedom of Contract
Under Article 1306 of the Civil Code, contracting parties may establish such stipulations, clauses, terms, and conditions as they may deem convenient, provided they are not contrary to law, morals, good customs, public order, or public policy. An indemnity clause permitting demand upon mere accrual of liability is a valid exercise of freedom of contract. The principal debtor is bound by the terms he freely accepted when obtaining the surety bond.

3. Surety Indemnity Rights
Under Article 2071 of the Civil Code, a guarantor or surety may proceed against the principal debtor even before paying the debt when the debtor is sued for payment or when the debt becomes demandable. This statutory provision safeguards the surety against potential insolvency of the principal debtor. When coupled with an express indemnity agreement authorizing immediate recovery upon demand, the surety possesses a clear legal right to demand indemnity from the debtor.

About these questions and answers
The questions reproduced here are the official texts of the Philippine Bar Examinations, published by the Supreme Court. They are reproduced for study purposes.The suggested answers are the author’s own.

They are not official answers, have no connection with the Supreme Court, the Office of the Bar Confidant, or any bar review institution, and are not endorsed by any of them. Official answer keys, where released, should be preferred over anything here.Nothing on this page is legal advice, and reading it creates no lawyer-client relationship. Do not rely on any suggested answer in an actual legal matter. Consult counsel on your own facts.Suggested answers reflect the law and jurisprudence the author considers applicable as of the date shown.

Where a question comes from an earlier examination, the suggested answer applies the law as it now stands, which may differ from the law in force when the question was given, and may therefore differ from what would have been the correct answer at that time. Where the difference is material, the answer notes it.The practice scoring feature measures wording overlap with the suggested answer. It is not a grade, carries no official weight, and says nothing about whether your reasoning is sound.Errors are possible. If you find one, please tell me and I will correct it.Last reviewed: October 2026