Mr. L sought legal advice from his lawyer, Atty. M, regarding the possibility of annulling his marriage. In the course of their conversation, Mr. L mentioned that he would be able to immediately pay Atty. M’s legal fees because he received a huge kickback from a favored supplier in relation to his work as member of his Municipality’s Bids and Awards Committee.
(a) Is the communication made by Mr. L to Atty. M regarding the kickback he received presumed to be confidential? Explain. (3%)
(b) What is the duty of a lawyer when, in the course of his representation, he discovered that his client committed fraud upon a person or a tribunal? (2%)
Suggested answer only. Not an official answer and not legal advice.
(a) Yes, Mr. L's statement on the kickback is presumed confidential. (b) A lawyer who discovers client fraud must prompt the client to rectify it, or terminate representation if the client refuses.
Under Rule 130, Section 24(b) of the Rules of Court and Canon III of the CPRA, client communications in professional employment are presumed confidential, unless in furtherance of a future crime or fraud. Under Canon III, Section 9, if a lawyer discovers client fraud upon a person or tribunal, the lawyer must urge rectification or withdraw.
Here, Mr. L's disclosure of a past kickback during an annulment consultation was not in aid of a future crime; thus, it is privileged and presumed confidential. Further, upon discovering client fraud, the lawyer must demand its rectification or sever the engagement.
Therefore, Mr. L's statement is presumed confidential, and Atty. M must require rectification of client fraud or withdraw.
This is not an official scoring system and carries no weight with the Supreme Court or any bar review provider. It measures how much of the suggested answer's wording your response covers, not whether your reasoning is correct. For practice only.
Quick check
Under Rule 130, Section 24(b), what is the legal status of a client's disclosure of a past crime made during legal consultation?
Disclosures of past crimes made during legal consultation are protected by attorney-client privilege.
When does the future crime or fraud exception apply to attorney-client privilege?
Privilege does not protect communications made to facilitate or commit a future crime or fraud.
Under Canon III, Section 9 of the CPRA, what must a lawyer do upon discovering client fraud upon a tribunal?
The lawyer must prompt the client to rectify the fraud and withdraw if the client refuses.
Why is a client's admission of a previously received kickback protected under attorney-client privilege?
Disclosures of past crimes are privileged because they are not made to facilitate a future offense.
If a client refuses to rectify a fraud committed upon a court despite the lawyer's advice, what is the lawyer's ethical duty?
If the client refuses to rectify fraud committed upon a tribunal, the lawyer must withdraw from representation.
Learn more about these topics
1. Attorney-Client Privilege
Under Rule 130, Section 24(b) of the Rules of Court and Canon III of the Code of Professional Responsibility and Accountability (CPRA), communications made by a client to an attorney in the course of professional employment are strictly confidential and privileged. This protection covers past crimes or illegal acts disclosed during consultations, encouraging clients to disclose all facts fully without fear of public exposure or prosecution. Unless the communication falls under a recognized statutory exception, the lawyer is legally bound to preserve client confidences indefinitely.
2. Future Crime Exception
The attorney-client privilege does not extend to communications made in furtherance of a future crime or perpetration of fraud. For the exception to apply, the client must consult the lawyer to facilitate, plan, or commit a crime or fraudulent act. Disclosures regarding completed past crimes, such as a kickback previously received by the client, remain fully covered by attorney-client privilege because they are not intended to aid or abet an ongoing or future criminal enterprise.
3. Rectification of Fraud
Under Canon III, Section 9 of the CPRA, when a lawyer discovers that a client has committed fraud upon a person or tribunal during the representation, the lawyer must immediately advise and urge the client to rectify the fraudulent act. If the client refuses or fails to rectify the fraud, the lawyer must promptly terminate the attorney-client relationship and withdraw from representation to avoid becoming complicit in illegal or unethical conduct before the court.