2019 Civil Law, Q18

In light of a new business venture, Mr. A entered into a lease contract with Mr. B involving one of the latter’s warehouses. One day, Mr. B, who was then encountering financial difficulties, approached Mr. A and sought for a loan, which Mr. A readily granted to him. In order to secure the loan obligation, Mr. B mortgaged the leased warehouse in favor of Mr. A. In addition, Mr. B executed a promissory note in favor of A, wherein prior demand was waived by him.
When Mr. B defaulted on his loan obligation, Mr. A simply stopped paying rentals due to Mr. B on the ground that legal compensation had already set in up to the concurrent amount. Furthermore, since there was still a balance due on the promissory note, Mr. A foreclosed the real estate mortgage over Mr. B’s property, without any prior demand furnished to Mr. B.
Aggrieved, Mr. B opposed the foreclosure due to the lack of prior demand, contending that the waiver of prior demand was stipulated in the promissory note and not in the mortgage instrument. Mr. B likewise argued that when Mr. A invoked legal compensation between the unpaid rentals and the loan arrearages, it amounted to a novation that resulted in the extinguishment of the loan contract between them. As such, the real estate mortgage, being a mere accessory contract to the principal loan, was necessarily extinguished.
(a) May Mr. A validly claim legal compensation? Explain. (2%)
(b) May Mr. A validly foreclose on the real estate mortgage even without prior demand to Mr. B? Explain. (2%)
(c) Is Mr. B’s claim of novation correct? Explain. (2%)

Quick check

Under Article 1279 of the Civil Code, when does legal compensation take effect between mutual debtors and creditors?

Under Article 1169 of the Civil Code, what is the legal effect when a promissory note contains an express waiver of demand?

Under Article 1292 of the Civil Code, what is required for an implied novation to extinguish a prior obligation?

How does invoking legal compensation between unpaid rentals and loan arrearages affect the underlying loan contract?

Choices available with full access.

Why was Mr. A entitled to foreclose the real estate mortgage without furnishing prior demand to Mr. B?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Legal Compensation
Under Article 1279 of the Civil Code, legal compensation takes effect by operation of law when two persons, in their own right, are creditors and debtors of each other. For legal compensation to take place, both debts must consist of a sum of money, be due, liquidated, and demandable, and neither debt must be subject to any retention or controversy. When these requisites concur, compensation extinguishes both debts to the concurrent amount, even without the knowledge or express consent of the parties.

2. Waiver of Demand
Under Article 1169 of the Civil Code, default or mora generally sets in only after the creditor judicially or extrajudicially demands fulfillment of the obligation. However, demand is unnecessary to establish default when the obligation or the law expressly so declares. A waiver of demand stipulated in a promissory note is valid and binding. When the debtor defaults pursuant to such waiver, the creditor may immediately proceed to foreclose the accessory real estate mortgage securing the principal promissory note.

3. Novation Requisites
Under Article 1292 of the Civil Code, in order that an obligation may be impliedly novated by another which substitutes the same, it is imperative that the two obligations be in every point incompatible with each other. Invoking legal compensation to offset mutual debts up to the concurrent amount does not constitute a novation. Instead, it operates as a mode of partial payment or legal extinguishment, leaving the unpaid balance of the principal loan and its accessory mortgage fully effective.

About these questions and answers
The questions reproduced here are the official texts of the Philippine Bar Examinations, published by the Supreme Court. They are reproduced for study purposes.The suggested answers are the author’s own.

They are not official answers, have no connection with the Supreme Court, the Office of the Bar Confidant, or any bar review institution, and are not endorsed by any of them. Official answer keys, where released, should be preferred over anything here.Nothing on this page is legal advice, and reading it creates no lawyer-client relationship. Do not rely on any suggested answer in an actual legal matter. Consult counsel on your own facts.Suggested answers reflect the law and jurisprudence the author considers applicable as of the date shown.

Where a question comes from an earlier examination, the suggested answer applies the law as it now stands, which may differ from the law in force when the question was given, and may therefore differ from what would have been the correct answer at that time. Where the difference is material, the answer notes it.The practice scoring feature measures wording overlap with the suggested answer. It is not a grade, carries no official weight, and says nothing about whether your reasoning is sound.Errors are possible. If you find one, please tell me and I will correct it.Last reviewed: October 2026