Prior to his death, H, married to W, with children X, Y, and Z, executed a holographic will entirely written, dated, and signed by him. In his will, H instituted W, X, and Y as his heirs, and consequently, made testamentary dispositions in their favor. H, however, expressly disinherited Z on the ground that the latter once filed a civil case against him in order to collect a particular sum of money he previously owed Z.
(a) Was the disinheritance of Z proper? Explain. (3%)
(b) Assuming that the disinheritance of Z was improper, how will it affect the institution of heirs and testamentary dispositions made in H’s will? Explain. (3%)
Suggested answer only. Not an official answer and not legal advice.
(a) No, Z's disinheritance was improper. (b) It annuls the institution of heirs insofar as it prejudices Z's legitime, leaving valid non-impairing testamentary dispositions. Under Article 916 of the Civil Code, disinheritance requires a legal cause specified by law
Unlock the full Civil Law answers365 days of full access. GCash, Maya and card accepted.
This is not an official scoring system and carries no weight with the Supreme Court or any bar review provider. It measures how much of the suggested answer's wording your response covers, not whether your reasoning is correct. For practice only.
Quick check
Under Article 916 of the Civil Code, how may a compulsory heir be validly disinherited?
Article 916 provides that disinheritance can only be effected through a valid will specifying a cause provided by law.
Which of the following is a valid statutory ground for disinheriting a child under Article 919 of the Civil Code?
Refusal without justifiable cause to provide support is an express ground for disinheriting a child under Article 919.
Why was H's disinheritance of his child Z legally improper?
Filing a civil suit to collect a debt is a lawful act and not a ground for disinheritance under Article 919.
What is the legal effect of an improper disinheritance under Article 918 of the Civil Code?
Choices available with full access.
What happens to devises and legacies made in a will when a compulsory heir is improperly disinherited?
Choices available with full access.
Learn more about these topics
1. Requisites of Disinheritance
Under Article 915 and Article 916 of the Civil Code, a compulsory heir may be deprived of his legitime through disinheritance only for causes expressly specified by law and effected through a valid will. The burden of proving the truth of the cause for disinheritance rests upon the other heirs of the testator if the disinherited heir denies it. If the cause relied upon by the testator is not among those enumerated under Articles 919, 920, or 921 of the Civil Code, the disinheritance is invalid and fails to deprive the heir of his compulsory legitime.
2. Collection Suit Effect
Under Article 919 of the Civil Code, the statutory grounds for disinheriting a child or descendant include an groundless accusation of a crime, attempt against life, or refusal to provide support. Filing a civil action to collect a lawful debt previously owed by the parent is a legitimate exercise of a legal right and does not constitute any of the exclusive grounds for disinheritance recognized by law. Consequently, disinheriting a child simply because he initiated a civil collection suit against his parent is legally improper and produces no legal effect against the child's compulsory right.
3. Improper Disinheritance Effect
Under Article 918 of the Civil Code, an improper or ineffective disinheritance does not render the entire will void. Instead, it annuls the institution of heirs made in the will only insofar as such institution prejudices or impairs the compulsory legitime of the improperly disinherited heir. Devises, legacies, and other testamentary dispositions made in favor of other persons remain valid and effective to the extent that they do not impair the disinherited compulsory heir's rightful share in the legitime under the law.