Due to serious business reverses, ABC Co. decided to terminate the services of several officers receiving “fat” compensation packages. One of these officers was Mr. X, its Vice-President for External Affairs and a member of the Board of Directors. Aggrieved, Mr. X filed a complaint for illegal dismissal before the National labor Relations Commission (NLRC) – Regional Arbitration Branch.
ABC Co. moved for the dismissal of the case on the ground of lack of jurisdiction, asserting that since Mr. X occupied the position of Vice-President for External Affairs which is listed in the by-laws of the corporation, the case should have been tiled before the Regional Trial Court.
The Labor Arbiter (LA) denied ABC Co.’s motion and proceeded to rule that Mr. X was illegally dismissed. Hence, he was reinstated in ABC Co.’s payroll pending its appeal to the NLRC.
(a) Did the LA err in denying ABC Co.’s motion to dismiss on the ground of lack of jurisdiction? Explain. (2.5%)
(b) Assuming the LA’s ruling of illegal dismissal with finality, may ABC Co. claim reimbursement for the amounts it paid to Mr. X during the time that he was on payroll reinstatement pending appeal? Explain. (2.5%)
Suggested answer only. Not an official answer and not legal advice.
(a) **Yes**, the Labor Arbiter erred in denying the motion to dismiss. (b) **No**, ABC Co. cannot claim reimbursement for amounts paid during payroll reinstatement. Under jurisprudence, an officer position listed in corporate by-laws makes
Unlock the full Labor Law answers365 days of full access. GCash, Maya and card accepted.
This is not an official scoring system and carries no weight with the Supreme Court or any bar review provider. It measures how much of the suggested answer's wording your response covers, not whether your reasoning is correct. For practice only.
Quick check
Which tribunal possesses exclusive jurisdiction over disputes involving the dismissal of a corporate officer whose position is listed in the corporate by-laws?
Dismissal disputes of corporate officers created by corporate by-laws are intra-corporate controversies under RTC jurisdiction.
Under the statutory test, how is a corporate officer distinguished from a regular corporate employee?
An individual is a corporate officer if their position is explicitly created or listed in corporate by-laws.
Under Article 229 of the Labor Code, what is the legal status of a Labor Arbiter's reinstatement order pending appeal?
A Labor Arbiter's order of reinstatement is immediately executory pending appeal.
Under the Garcia v. PAL doctrine, can an employer recover salaries paid to an employee during payroll reinstatement if the reinstatement order is later reversed?
Choices available with full access.
Why did the Labor Arbiter lack jurisdiction over Mr. X's illegal dismissal complaint against ABC Co.?
Choices available with full access.
Learn more about these topics
1. Intra-Corporate Controversy Jurisdiction
Under Republic Act No. 8799 (The Securities Regulation Code) and corporate jurisprudence, disputes involving the removal or dismissal of corporate officers fall under the original and exclusive jurisdiction of the Regional Trial Courts (RTC) acting as Special Commercial Courts, rather than the Labor Arbiter. An intra-corporate controversy arises when the relationship between the parties is intrinsically linked to corporate governance or charter provisions, and the controversy pertains to the enforcement of corporate rights, duties, or corporate officer tenure under the Corporation Code and corporate by-laws.
2. Corporate Officer Test
To determine whether a dismissed individual is a corporate officer or a regular employee, Philippine labor jurisprudence applies the statutory and by-law test. A corporate officer is one whose position is expressly created and listed in the Articles of Incorporation or corporate by-laws, or appointed pursuant to specific by-law provisions by the Board of Directors. When an individual occupies a position explicitly created by corporate by-laws, such as Vice-President for External Affairs, any dismissal complaint constitutes an intra-corporate dispute cognizable exclusively by the RTC.
3. Reinstatement Refund Prohibition
Under Article 229 of the Labor Code and the landmark doctrine established in Garcia v. Philippine Airlines, Inc., an order of reinstatement issued by a Labor Arbiter is immediately executory pending appeal. If the Labor Arbiter's decision finding illegal dismissal is later reversed or set aside on appeal or judicial review, the employer cannot claim reimbursement or refund of the salaries and allowances paid to the employee during the period of actual or payroll reinstatement, as such payments are grounded on equity and social justice.