Primo, a French national and permanent resident of Canada, executed in the Philippines a holographic will which he entirely wrote, dated and signed. Primo enumerated in the will various real and personal properties situated in the Philippines, France and Canada. Primo bequeathed the properties in the Philippines to his parents, the properties in France to his siblings, and the properties in Canada to his wife and children. In 2024, Primo suffered a heart attack and died in Australia while attending a conference. Primo was survived by his wife, two children, parents, and three siblings. What laws shall govern the formalities of Primo’s holographic will, the distribution of his estate, and the qualifications of his heirs? Explain.
Suggested answer only. Not an official answer and not legal advice.
Philippine law governs the formalities of Primo's holographic will, while French law governs the estate distribution and heirs' qualifications.
Under Articles 17 and 817 of the Civil Code, the formal validity of a will executed in the Philippines by an alien is governed by Philippine law as the lex loci celebrationis. Under Article 16, paragraph 2, and Article 1039, the intrinsic validity, successional rights, and capacity to succeed are governed by the decedent's national law.
Here, as Primo executed his holographic will in the Philippines, Philippine law governs its formalities. Since Primo is a French national, French law governs the distribution of his estate and capacity of his heirs, regardless of property locations or his place of death.
Therefore, Philippine law governs the formalities, while French law governs the estate distribution and qualifications of heirs.
This is not an official scoring system and carries no weight with the Supreme Court or any bar review provider. It measures how much of the suggested answer's wording your response covers, not whether your reasoning is correct. For practice only.
Quick check
What law governs the formal validity of a holographic will executed in the Philippines by a foreign national?
Under Article 17 and Article 817 of the Civil Code, the formal validity of a will executed in the Philippines is governed by Philippine law as the lex loci celebrationis.
Under Article 16, paragraph 2 of the Civil Code, what law governs the intrinsic validity and distribution of a decedent's estate?
Article 16, paragraph 2 explicitly provides that intrinsic validity and successional rights are governed by the national law of the decedent.
Under Article 1039 of the Civil Code, what law determines the capacity and qualifications of heirs to succeed to an estate?
Article 1039 provides that capacity to succeed is governed by the national law of the decedent.
Which law governs the formal validity of Primo's holographic will executed while in the Philippines?
Philippine law governs the formalities of the will because it was executed within the Philippines.
Why does French law govern the distribution of Primo's estate and the qualifications of his legal heirs?
French law applies to the distribution and qualifications of heirs because French law was Primo's national law.
Learn more about these topics
1. Formal Validity Rule
Under Article 17, in relation to Article 817 of the Civil Code, the forms and solemnities of contracts, wills, and other public instruments executed in the Philippines are governed by Philippine law as the lex loci celebrationis. When an alien executes a holographic will in the Philippines, its extrinsic or formal validity is determined by compliance with Philippine statutory formalities. Consequently, a holographic will entirely written, dated, and signed by the hand of the testator in the Philippines is formally valid under Philippine law regardless of the testator's nationality or citizenship.
2. National Law Principle
Under Article 16, paragraph 2 of the Civil Code, intestate and testamentary successions, with respect to the order of succession, the amount of successional rights, and the intrinsic validity of testamentary provisions, are regulated by the national law of the person whose succession is under consideration. This rule applies regardless of the nature or location of the real or personal properties comprising the estate. Therefore, when a French national dies leaving properties in various countries, French law exclusively governs the distribution, order of successional rights, and intrinsic validity of his testamentary dispositions.
3. Capacity to Succeed
Under Article 1039 of the Civil Code, capacity to succeed is governed by the law of the nation of the decedent. The qualifications, rights, and disqualifications of compulsory or testamentary heirs are determined by the decedent's national law rather than the law of the place where the properties are situated or where the decedent died or resided. Thus, for a French decedent, the determination of who qualifies as heirs and their respective successional rights is governed by French law.