Troy owns a parcel of commercial land situated in R. Magsaysay Avenue, Davao City. On January 1, 2015, Troy and Bolton entered into a 10-year contract of lease for PHP 100,000.00 per month. They agreed that Bolton can construct a two- storey building on the land for the operation of the latter’s grocery store. Immediately upon assuming possession of the property, Bolton constructed a two- storey building thereon that cost PHP 10 million. Upon the expiration of the lease, Troy told Bolton that he was no longer extending the same and demanded that Bolton vacate the premises without demolishing the structure. Bolton did not register any objection but demanded PHP 10 million as reimbursement for the building. Bolton claimed that as a builder in good faith, he is entitled to full reimbursement of the useful improvements with a right of retention until fully paid. Troy refused to pay. Should Troy fully reimburse Bolton? Explain.
Suggested answer only. Not an official answer and not legal advice.
No, Troy is not required to fully reimburse Bolton. Under Article 1678 of the Civil Code, a lessee is not a builder in good faith under Article 448 because he possesses the property temporarily. A lessee introducing useful improvements in good faith has no
Unlock the full Civil Law answers365 days of full access. GCash, Maya and card accepted.
This is not an official scoring system and carries no weight with the Supreme Court or any bar review provider. It measures how much of the suggested answer's wording your response covers, not whether your reasoning is correct. For practice only.
Quick check
Why is a lessee who constructs a building on leased land not considered a builder in good faith under Article 448 of the Civil Code?
A lessee is not a builder in good faith under Article 448 because his possession is temporary and he knows from the outset that he does not own the land.
Under Article 1678 of the Civil Code, what amount must a lessor pay if he elects to appropriate useful improvements introduced in good faith by a lessee?
Under Article 1678 of the Civil Code, if the lessor chooses to retain the useful improvements made in good faith, he is liable to pay only one-half of their value at the time of lease termination.
What is the primary recourse of a lessee if the lessor refuses to reimburse one-half of the value of useful improvements under Article 1678?
If the lessor refuses to reimburse one-half of the value of useful improvements, the lessee's sole remedy is to remove them without causing unnecessary impairment to the principal property.
Does a lessee have a right of retention over the leased property pending reimbursement for useful improvements under civil law?
Choices available with full access.
Why was Troy not obligated to fully reimburse Bolton PHP 10 million for the building upon the expiration of their lease?
Choices available with full access.
Learn more about these topics
1. Lessee Not Builder
Under Philippine civil law, Article 448 on builders in good faith does not apply to a lessee who constructs improvements on leased land. A lessee is not a possessor in good faith in the concept of an owner, as he knows his possession is temporary and limited to the lease term. Applying Article 448 would allow a tenant to "improve" the landlord out of his property. Consequently, the rights regarding improvements made by a lessee are governed exclusively by Article 1678 of the Civil Code.
2. Useful Improvements
Under Article 1678 of the Civil Code, when a lessee introduces useful improvements in good faith that are suitable to the lease without altering the property's form or substance, the lessor has the option to keep them by paying one-half of their value at the time the lease terminates. The option belongs solely to the lessor, not the lessee. If the lessor refuses to reimburse one-half of the value, the lessee's recourse is to remove the improvements without causing unnecessary impairment to the property.
3. No Retention Right
Unlike a builder in good faith under Article 546 of the Civil Code, a lessee possesses no right of retention over the leased property pending reimbursement for useful improvements. Because a lessee acknowledges the landlord's title from the inception of the contract, he cannot refuse to vacate the premises upon the expiration of the lease. Any demand by the lessee to retain possession until full reimbursement is made lacks legal basis, and he must surrender the property upon the lease's termination.